Showing posts with label Forbes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Forbes. Show all posts

Monday, February 04, 2013

AVG Technologies - IPO One Year Birthday. Growth Curve or Ski Slope for 2013? Forbes versus Seeking Alpha Contributors



AVG Technologies has now been public for a year.  Their IPO (Initial Public Offering) took place in early February, 2012,  The stock   closed around $13.08 on its opening day last February  on Nasdaq  after targeting an opening day price at $16 plus.   The stock closed  on February 2, 2013  at  $13.14.  These two figures represent a one-year return of 0.38% excluding transaction costs and any dividends paid.  For the first 9 months of their fiscal year, AVG Technologies  revenue was up, but net income was down (not good as a trend).   Over the course of the year, AVG had a low of $9.42 and in December, had a high of $16.38. They have toolbar  deals with both Google and Yahoo.

 A Motley Fool Perspective - February

One worries about the thoroughness of AVG's protection, however, when one sees they've not been very thorough in safeguarding their finances. Current ratio is a quick-and-easy indicator of a stock's health, especially for a smaller company such as AVG which may lack the resources to bail itself out in the long term. With a current ratio of 0.7, AVG is struggling.
But T.M., you might say, AVG could be using its profits to expand, research, etc. etc. Their declining margins,  however, tell another tale: one of a company whose long-term solvency and profitability is in doubt.

 http://beta.fool.com/tmloyd/2013/02/11/world-wide-web-investment-here-today-gone-tomorrow/23612/?ticker=AVG

So what do Forbes contributor Jim Oberweis and Seeking Alpha contributor Eiad Asbahi see for the company? 

3 Slow Growth Small-Caps with Big Potential – Forbes 

Forbes’ numbers are inaccurate in the article.  AVG Technologies has more than 110 million computer users.  While they have been losing share, according to Opswat, they claim an active user base of 143 million users.  Some of this is attributable to 25 million copies of their Internet Security Suite (the paid) product given to purchasers of Huawei (Yes, that Huawei) mobile devices, in India.  

Forbes contributor Jim Oberweis likes AVG for the company’s PEG ratio, growth prospects, and the fact that the free product received a PC Magazine Editor’s choice award.  He likes the Google relationship. See links at the bottom of this blog for relative rankings of the paid AVG Antivirus and AVG Internet Security  solutions. The print article will be in the February 11 issue.
 

AVG: Feb 1st Google Policy Updates Threaten AVG's Growth Engine, Signals Steep Downside

In a  January 31 Seeking Alpha article,  Seeking Alpha contributor Eiad Asbahi is forecasting a share price of $8.50 to $10 per share (elsewhere in the analysis, the figures are $7.30 to $10.28).  This is based on an extensive quantitative analysis based on a supposed change that will be occurring in Google’s toolbar policy.   

According to the article, “Google (GOOG), AVG's primary search partner and currently the source of substantially all of AVG's Platform-derived revenue, is on the verge of announcing an update to its toolbar policy, something that has not been widely followed or discussed by market participants.”  This would require companies to make use of “opt-out” instead of having “opt-in” checked automatically on the customer’s behalf.  Opt-in has been a point of consternation among many users of many software packages.

In the article, he mentions Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer was asked about this policy change.  Her response,   "On the Toolbar change from Google, we'd be remiss to offer comment on another company's product, so I'm not going to comment further there.”  AVG Technologies has a toolbar  agreement with Yahoo as well as Google. Previously, they had been exclusively one company or the other.

Asbahi did some number crunching based on different churn rates for users prior to and after February 1, 2012, an opt-in rate of 65% and per user revenue from Yahoo search bar users at 50% of Google tool bar users.  After all of his number crunching,  his estimates for AVG Technologies 2013 revenue to be between $248M and $287M,  an “ implied market capitalization and target price would between $399M and $569M, or $7.34/share and $10.28/share respectively.” On CNETs download site, AVG averages around a million downloads a week, suggesting major churn.

From a November 1 Financial Times blog,  “J R Smith, chief executive of AVG, admits that being the first in the industry to offer free products has “kind of put us a little bit in a box”, but slowly the company is succeeding in convincing investors that AVG has evolved from offering just hardcore security into other services and platforms”  http://blogs.ft.com/beyond-brics/2012/11/01/corporate-watch-avg-breaks-out

AVG made a buy versus make decision regarding mobile security in November 2010 with a $4.1 million acquisition of Droidsecurity to gain entry into mobile security market. 

AVG Technologies should be reporting their earnings on February 21.    
    
For some comparative reviews of paid antivirus and internet security products by PC Magazine, go to:

 
About OPSWAT www.opswat.com    

Founded in 2002, OPSWAT is the industry leader in software management SDKs, interoperability certification, and multiple-engine scanning solutions.

OPSWAT market share reports are available at http://www.opswat.com/media/reports    


Monday, February 06, 2012

AVG Technologies Goes Public With Their IPO on NYSE

AVG Technologies' two year (?) trek to go public occurred on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) on February 1. For a while, the street had the IPO taking place on the London or Warsaw Stock Exchange. The planned opening Thursday morning on the NYSE was to be somewhere in the range of $16-18 US. Instead, it opened slightly lower and closed at $13.00 on Thursday for a 19% drop. Friday’s close was $13.09. A negative first day pop is never the objective. A positive pop rewards the initial investors, generates buzz, etc.

The three lead underwriters for the IPO (Initial Public Offering) were Morgan Stanley, J.P. Morgan and Goldman Sachs. Those underwriters will also be leading the Facebook IPO.

First Day Press on the IPO (some of the links may have changed)

Financial Times - AVG: not feeling the love

http://blogs.ft.com/beyond-brics/2012/02/02/polands-avg-http://www.blogger.com/img/blank.gifnot-feeling-the-nyse-love/#axzz1lT3sEdh6

Czechposition.com - Shares in Czech anti-virus software firm AVG tank in NYSE debut, despite solid fundamentals

http://www.ceskapozice.cz/en/business/markets-finance/shares-czech-anti-virus-software-firm-avg-tank-nyse-debut-despite-solid-fun

NY Times - Facebook I.P.O. Lifts Some Tech Stocks

http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2012/02/02/facebook-i-p-o-lifts-some-tech-stocks/

Forbes - IPOs: Let's Hope Facebook’s Deal Goes Better than AVG's

http://www.forbes.com/sites/ericsavitz/2012/02/02/ipos-lets-hope-facebooks-deal-goes-better-than-avgs/

Deal Pipeline- AVG IPO gets no Facebook boost

http://www.thedeal.com/content/tmt/avg-ipo-gets-no-facebook-boost.php#ixzz1lTJ4XouF

Reuters - AVG Tech shares crash on market debut. This headline was later amended to AVG Tech shares fall on market debut

http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/02/02/us-avgtech-idUSTRE8112EZ20120202

What Happened?

That’s probably being asked in Prague and Amsterdam. Doing a valuation and pricing a private company for an IPO is an inexact science. Market conditions have changed (actually for the better over the last few months). The “guys in the room” may have been overly optimistic in their forecasts they used to generate their valuation of AVG and then back calculating to $16-18 dollar price. Buyers may be sitting back. It’s a positive sign that the original investors sold only a portion of their stock.

One article mentioned that at the offering price, AVG's price-to-earnings ratio was about 15. The writer stated that this made the shares more costly than those of Symantec, whose shares trade at a P-E ratio of about 11. This isn’t a completely fair comparison. Symantec isn’t s a pure security play given that they own VeriSign. Symantec’s mix of business and consumer security software is different. They have a broader overall security portfolio. They also sell security appliances. Hardware security firms tend to have lower multiples.

AVG Technologies Has Relatively Solid Products

• AV- Test www.av-test.org - They came in sixth out of 23 in Av –Tests’s Q4 testing. Kaspersky topped this test.
• VB100 (Virus Bulletin, www.virusbtn.com ) - AVG was 5 for 6 in receiving VB100 awards during 2011 for tests they were in.
• AV-Comparatives www.av-comparatives.org – (1) AVG Technologies was 11th in av-comparatives August-December “Whole Product “Real World” Dynamic Protection Test”. Symantec topped this one. (2) AVG received 2 stars out of 3 and finished 14th out of 18 in the “On Demand Detection of Malicious Software Test”. Kaspersky won av-comparative’s Product of the Year award.
• PC Magazine - They scored 3.0 stars out of 5 in PC Magazine’s Internet Security Suites 2012 testing. Symantec topped this test with 4.5 stars.
• PC World – They scored 4.0 stars out of 5 along with 7 other companies in PC World’s Best Internet Security Suites 2012 reviews. G Data topped this testing with 4.5 stars.

Now that AVG Technologies has gone public, there will be more visibility into the company. More "numbers"will be available for analysts and the public to view - where revenues are coming from, margins, financing, banking, and all that good stuff. More visibility will be given to projections (with the caveats that all public firms make). Analysts may look at churn, which is about 50%, based on AVG’s installed based of just over 100 million users and over 50 million downloads annually on download.com .